Nampa, Idaho — A trusted community figure is now at the center of a criminal investigation after 45-year-old Robert Mendez Esquivel, a priest at St. Paul’s Catholic Church in Nampa, was arrested on August 27, 2025. Detectives say Esquivel, widely known among parishioners as Father Toto, faces charges of sexual battery of a minor aged 16 to 17 years old.
Police confirmed that the incident which led to Esquivel’s arrest did not involve a juvenile from the church or its affiliated school, but the revelation has still rattled parishioners and neighbors alike.
Details from the Investigation
The arrest followed an extensive inquiry by the Nampa Police Department’s Persons Crimes Detectives, who have been working to piece together the events leading up to the allegations.
According to a probable cause affidavit made public, investigators allege that Esquivel first came into contact with the victim through a dating application. The victim, whose name has been withheld due to their age, reportedly connected online with a user listed as “Robert.” Detectives later confirmed the account belonged to Esquivel.
The affidavit details that communication between Esquivel and the minor eventually led to an encounter that resulted in the current criminal charge.
Community Reaction
The arrest of Esquivel has left many in Nampa stunned. For years, he had been a recognizable face at St. Paul’s, leading services, attending community events, and known by parishioners for his warm personality. Now, his congregation and the wider community are grappling with both disappointment and disbelief.
One longtime churchgoer described the mood in the parish as “a mix of sadness, confusion, and a need for answers.”
Police Statement and Call for Information
The Nampa Police Department has underscored that the investigation is ongoing and that detectives are actively working to determine whether there may be additional victims.
“We understand the deep impact this arrest has within the community,” the department said in a public statement. “Our priority remains with the victim, and we encourage anyone with information to step forward.”
Those with information are urged to call Crime Stoppers at 208-343-COPS or submit a tip online at www.343.cops.com. Tips can be provided anonymously.
What Comes Next
As the case proceeds through the legal system, Esquivel remains in custody. The Catholic Diocese of Boise, which oversees St. Paul’s Catholic Church, has not yet issued a public comment on the arrest, though many expect an official response in the coming days.
For now, Nampa residents are left processing the shocking news and the difficult conversations it brings — about trust, accountability, and the importance of protecting young people both online and in the community.
“This is the kind of story no one ever wants to hear, especially about someone in a position of faith and leadership,” one resident shared. “But if this happened, then it’s right that the truth comes out and justice is served.”
The investigation remains active, and further updates will be shared as they become available.
Leave a Reply